Keep/toss/add for April baby girl

[heisenberg]

Anyone up for a little keep/toss/add? We just found out that our April baby is a girl and have a very preliminary list.

Last name is German, three syllables, starts with "Gr," and ends in "er." Basically nothing flows with it, so we just need to avoid names that clash. We like relatively classic names that are easy to spell. Popularity is not a huge issue, but I think we'd probably like to avoid the top 20 or so. Nothing too cutesy.  We have no middle name ideas yet and no obvious family members to recognize.  Our son is Os.car Vinc.ent. Thanks for your help! I lurk here often.

Margot
Iris
Fiona
Naomi
Mabel
Caitlin

[billyhorrible]

Margot - keep (add Margaret, Molly)

Iris - keep (add Iseult, Imogen, Elise)

Fiona - toss (sub Claudia, Bianca, Anya)

Naomi - toss (sub Noemi, Desdemona, Heidi)

Mabel - toss (sub Estella, Sylvie, Ruby)

Caitlin - keep (add Catherine, Caroline)

[lormor]

Keep:
Iris
Fiona
Mabel

My mind has gone blank. I'll have to come back to add.

[Widget123]

Keep Margot, Fiona, Iris. Toss the rest. Add Ivy, Talia.

[reginaphalange]

Toss Caitlin and Naomi. I would trade Iris for Ivy and I love the rest so I'll just rank them.

1. Fiona
2. Ivy
3. Mabel
4. Margot

[ourcrazynavylife]

heisenberg just stopping by to say hi!! Haha I think we have very similar name tastes

The ladies here are super helpful

[helenahhandbasket]

Keep Margot, Iris and Naomi

Add Ingrid, Maeve, Elise, Pearl, Beatrice, Vera, Sarah

[heisenberg]

Thanks for all of the suggestions! I'm loving Ivy for the middle spot (depending on what we choose).

Sylvie, Catherine, and Beatrice have been nixed by the husband already.

Ingrid and Margaret are on our long list, and I'll run Maeve by him.

ETA: I like Noemi, but I think it'll be a hard sell for the husband. He doesn't want her to have to spell both first and last names, and it seems less common than Naomi. I'll probably nix Caitlin for the same reason since there are about eleventy billion variants.

[cabbagecabbage]

Margot-keep
Iris-keep
Fiona-keep
Naomi-toss. I like it but not as much as others
Mabel-keep
Caitlin-toss

Add: Georgia, Beatrice, Alice

[rainbowbridge14]

Keep Iris, Fiona and Margot.

Iris is my favorite by far but if you like Ivy in the middle then I think Fiona Ivy is wonderful.

Add: Simone and Cora.

[honeylemon]

Margot - Eh. I prefer Margaret, but Margot is fine

Iris - I have an Iris so yes KEEP

Fiona - keep

Naomi - toss

Mabel - toss

Caitlin - toss

ADD: Beatrice, Felicity, Freya, Imogen, June

[heisenberg]

Thanks again, everyone. Love Beatrice. Maybe I can convince the husband.

[seamonster]

Margot- keep
Iris - toss
Fiona -toss
Naomi - keep
Mabel - toss
Caitlin-toss



Add:
Astrid
Annika
Mara
Katrina

[dreadpiratebuttercup]

Keep Iris and maybe Margot. I have an Iris, so I obviously think it's s winner.

[Deleted]

Margot - add Margaret, Martha
Iris - toss (sub Viola)
Fiona - toss -
Naomi - toss (sub Mara - there is actually a biblical connection if you're into that)
Mabel - sub Miriam
Caitlin - toss

[bromios]

Margot - Toss
Iris - KEEP and use!
Fiona - keepish
Naomi - Keep
Mabel - toss
Caitlin - toss

Add:
Alice
Clara
Eve
Flora
Frances
Iona
Julia
Mira
Marie
Noelle
Petra
Philippa
Thea
Valerie