Favorite eyeliner recs!

[ashleymarie26]

I've tried:

Benefit They're real! (Meh)
Marc Jacobs (good, but too smudgy)
Kat Von D tattoo (this is my fav so far, but it dried out after about 4 weeks, which seemed really fast).

I tend to like the cleaner, more defined lines better than a smokey or blended look.

So tell me, what's your favorite!?

[abvintage]

Stila Stay All Day is a felt tip that is pretty good.


NYX Noir is great but you may want your own eyeliner brush to use


Edit: to keep your KVD from drying out dip the tip into makeup brush cleanser and wipe onto a soft/smooth towel gently until it's a consistent line again. 

[Deleted]

It Cosmetics No Tug eyeliner. I have issues with eyeliners smudging and this stays put and applies flawlessly

www.itcosmetics.com/no-tugr-waterproof-gel-eyeliner

[Ee]

I have tried just about every eyeliner there is. My current favorite is the $6 NYX collection noir matte liner. It's a twist up. It goes on very clean and doesn't smudge.

[ashleymarie26]

Oct 12, 2016 15:48:31 GMT -5 Cdnfroggy said:

I was coming in to rec the Kat Von D. I'm on month 3 of mine without any problems.

I wonder if I got a dud in this case.

[cadien]

Sephora Retractable Waterproof. Because my eyes water constantly and it's the only one I've found that really doesn't smear. And 22 colors!

[helenahhandbasket]

I like Maybelline stiletto. It's a felt tip liquid eyeliner

[sarahdawn]

I like urban decay

[summerbabe]

I like the stila stay all day liquid.

[madamewaffles]

+1 to Bobbi Brown gel liners. Also the Marc Jacobs gel pencils.

[yummeecookee]

Bare Minerals lasting line.

[silverspoon]

Urban Decay 24/7 liners. They really do stay all day.

[peppapig]

Love gel liners! I line with pencil first then go over it with gel and it's really smooth and precise.

[sassypantzz]

Oct 12, 2016 16:08:54 GMT -5 @martini said:

Oct 12, 2016 15:40:50 GMT -5 @piperanne said:

It Cosmetics No Tug eyeliner. I have issues with eyeliners smudging and this stays put and applies flawlessly

www.itcosmetics.com/no-tugr-waterproof-gel-eyeliner

+1. Best I've ever used.

Late to the party but this is also my fav

[sunfrogger88]

Oct 12, 2016 15:53:02 GMT -5 ashleymarie26 said:

Oct 12, 2016 15:48:31 GMT -5 Cdnfroggy said:

I was coming in to rec the Kat Von D. I'm on month 3 of mine without any problems.

I wonder if I got a dud in this case.

I don't make up well but my regular size has lasted 3+ years with no issue so, I think you got a dud.