This is Us **SPOILERS**

[jwinct]

Spoiler Alert

Spoiler Alert

Um, holy crap.

They won't kill Toby, right? Because "nothing bad happens on Christmas Eve." RIGHT?! I did NOT see that coming at all. As he fell, I thought, "Can't this poor family have one happy holiday??" Poor Kate is depressed enough; she can't lose Toby! 

I thought the scene with Randall and his co-worker was amazing. That speech about loving your kids hard and they will forgive you will definitely be the catalyst to him forgiving Rebecca. 

And can we talk about William being gay? I wasn't expecting that, either, but I loved it. I enjoyed the levity of the scene with Randall's daughter saying, "Grampa's gay... or at least bi" (or however she said it) and Randall just standing there, dumbfounded. 

I like Kevin and Sloan together - I think she's adorable. I do wonder how that play will do, if they get it up and running themselves. 

[hikingmama222]

FYI you can see the first two lines of the post on the home page in tapatalk...

[hikingmama222]

I'll be so upset if Toby dies. I really like him and Kate together. She deserves to be happy.

Didn't see William being gay at all. Loved that scene as well!

[jwinct]

I'm sorry - I didn't even think of that! I just edited the post; hopefully that helps.

Maybe he will live and this will be what they both need to actually commit to losing the weight.

[hikingmama222]

It's fixed jwinct! I really hope so!

[iwantbacon]

Loved Randall's daughter, like "Uh duh, Dad. Whatevs."

When Toby got there, i started crying very happy tears. When he fell over, very sad tears. I would be shocked if they killed him off. Then again, everything in their lives changed since their birthday, so it wouldn't be unheard of for him to go.

[adouces06]

Toby can't die. Nothing bad happens on Christmas Eve! It was a big enough surprise when he showed up, but then for him to collapse?! Ugh.

And I totally agree jwinct. The scene with Randall's coworker was excellent. And I thought for sure he jumped when his wife walked out.

Sloan and Kevin are adorable. And never saw it coming that William was gay. This show is so good.

[mg0202]

I like Toby , I hope he makes it.

Love Randall and Beth. William always has the perfect things to say.

I was surprised about William's boyfriend. Loved the kids reaction though.

hated Olivia hope she is gone for good, but I doubt it.