Our masculine picks are becoming feminine.

[emoxymoose]

So we're having boy # 3, we were set on Emerson but it seems that the trend is that it's becoming a female name. We even considered Emory, but again Emery is becoming popular on the female side. Can someone help me out with some non unisex names? Rules being that it has to be somewhat easy to pronounce and spell and cannot be higher than 200ish on the SSA names list.

DS 1 is Garrett (my choice)
DS 2 is Dean (H's choice, I was never thrilled)

[lormor]

I think Emerson is all boy.

Emmett
Scott
Brett
Harrison
Edgar

Off the top of my head, based on your other names.

[emoxymoose]

Thank you! I do too, but I get annoyed at every female Madison and Addison I meet too. I'm so conflicted.

[dreadpiratebuttercup]

Emerson is and always will be a boy name, no matter how many girls have the name. That being said, I'm not a fan.

Alexander
Aaron
Conall
Finnegan
Harlan
Isaac
James
Malcolm
Owen

[Widget123]

Honestly, I would steer clear of any baby name that has "Em" in it for boys. I even know of a baby Emmett that is a girl. I'm not sure I have a good sense of your style though so I will forego suggesting names until I do.

[helenahhandbasket]

Emerson is masculine, but if you feel weird about using it I get it.

I really like Garrett. I feel like it's a name I don't hear often, but it's highly recognizable and easy to pronounce.

Other names like that:
Raymond
Gregory
Franklin
Bennett
Wesley
Heath
Quentin
Lawrence

[emoxymoose]

Thank you everyone, naming is the worst part of being pregnant for me. I overthink it all, but I love all the suggestions.

[ottertails]

I truly believe you should use a name if you love it, no matter what. I will always see -son names as masculine no matter how many females are given a name with that ending. However, since popularity and names that are shared between sexes bother you, I'd drop both Emerson and Emory (I included available numbers below for popularity with variant spellings combined)

For births in 2014,
Emerson (1670), Emersyn (742), Emmerson (155), Emmersyn (76), Emersen (45), Emmersen (16), Emersynn (12) = 2716 girls
Emerson (1048), Emmerson (30), Emersyn (20), Emersen (11) = 1109 boys
Emery (2026), Emory (373), Emerie (293), Emry (138), Emeri (122), Emmarie (113), Emmery (71), Emree (88), Emrie (73), Emorie (45), Emori (40), Emri (35), Emrey (20), Emoree (16), Emmary (15), Emmry (15), Emeree (14), Emaree (13), Emmerie (11), Emmeri (10), Emmory (7), Emerii (6), Emmari (5), Emyri (5), Emmrie (5) = 3559 girls
Emery (361), Emory (252), Emry (45), Emori (8), Emeri (8) = 674 boys

Numbers come from namenerds. The author combines spellings to make a list that depicts how popular a name is (or at least feels) compared to the SSA list. Links below if you want to see them for yourself: 
Boys: link 
Girls: (if you want to double check) link  

I figured those links would be more helpful since I'm not really sure your style  Here are some other options that came to mind: 
Abram
Anders 
Arthur 
Hugo
Leon
Reuben  
Saul

[emoxymoose]

Thank you! I'm so neurotic about popularity of names that I was adding up all the spellings myself. Anderson is on our list with nn Anders, I think it's really cute.

From all these suggestions our current list:

Anderson, Anders
Tobias
Archer

[bluedot]

Everett
Emmett
Elliott
Oliver
Jasper
Henry
Harrison
Archer
Paul
Frank
Fredrick
William
Peter

[Deleted]

Emerson is a boy name. Period, end of story. I hate that it's being used for girls. That being said, I'm not a fan of Emerson at all.

Some other suggestions:

Evan
Thomas
Michael
William
James
Matthew
Justin
Scott
Daniel
Alexander
Christopher
Vincent
Jason
Anthony
Andrew
Bruce
Cameron
Zachary
Alan
Patrick
Jonathan