Sister for Anna

[bromios]

I feel like Josephine is the clear winner out of these (I would say Victoria if you weren't planning on calling her Tori). Suggestions:
Beatrix
Clara
Cora
Eve
Frances
Iris
Julia
Livia
Lenore
Mira
Mina
Marie
Petra
Rose
Simone
Thea

[Deleted]

The only name on your list I would use is Josephine, the rest are NMS. Emma & Anna does seem matchy IMO.
Suggestions:
Celia
Daphne
Harriet
Isobel
Louise
Margaret
Rosalie
Violet

[joy]

Emma and Anna are way too matchy.

I actually don't like when siblings have the same endings to their names, so that also removes Victoria (beautiful) and Olivia (meh).

Anna and Josephine complement each other beautifully.

I hate the nickname Josie, but that seems to be an unpopular opinion.

[friendofdobby]

Victoria and Josephine are the best match with Anna. I actually like the NN Tori as well as Josie.

[Stormtroopooper]

I'm also team Josephine, but I dislike Josie. It's too cutesy for my taste. I have and always will love Olivia, but if popularity bugs you, I'd say it's definitely out.

Suggestions:

Beatrice
Catherine
Dorothy
Elisabeth
Genevieve
Isobel
Juliet
Lucy
Magnolia
Nell
Olive
Ruby
Seraphina

[helenahhandbasket]

Well, I'm going to unabashedly vote for Josephine. I have one and we call her Josie and I have gotten a lot of positive feedback in her name.

My second choice for you is Victoria (funny enough, this was also on my long list for Josie, also with the NN Tori).

Suggesting
Sylvie
Sarah
Veronica
Frances
Theresa - NN Tessa
Catherine
Emily
Marie

[reginaphalange]

Everything joy said but I do like the nn Josie even though I'm not really a nn person.

What about Eliza, Eleanor, Hazel, Penelope, Beatrice

[starfishy]

Josephine/Josie is our girl pick so I love it!

I also love some of the other suggestions you've already been given. I think you can find something to go with Anna. We love Anna too, but already have a few Anna names running around our family

[Deleted]

Victoria is the clear winner. But, as a Victoria myself, I loathe the nn Tori. Vicki or Vicky is so much better.

[dreadpiratebuttercup]

Josephine, definitely. I also love Victoria, but not with Tori as the nn.

[Oliver's Bear]

Emma -- toss
Victoria -- keep
Josephine -- keep
Olivia -- toss

I'd keep both Victoria and Josephine, but I do not care for the nickname options you would use.

Suggestions:
Louisa
Elaine
Irene

[cabbagecabbage]

Of your list, I vote Josephine/Josie hands down. I love it and it's a great pairing.

Emma is too matchy and at near Olivia levels of popularity in its own right. Olivia is so oversaturated that I just can't be into it. I am not a big fan of Tori although Victoria on its own is lovely.

To expand your list, I think these would be great with Anna:

Jane
Mae
Adelle
Lydia
Julia
Beth, Betsy, Betty (Elizabeth)
Lucy




ETA I answered without reading, so it's funny to see I agreed with the class.

[spicysalmonroll]

Anna was going to be my girl choice, but I'm having a boy!
I love Josephine.
also love & suggest- Elena, Nina, Camilla

[normadix]

Josephine wins hands down for me. I like Emma but really don't like it with sister Anna.

[Flair Underwood]

Emma -- toss
Victoria -- toss
Josephine -- keep
Olivia -- toss

Josephine is the best, I agree.

Suggestions:
Elizabeth
Jolene
Justina

[lormor]

Your screen name makes me so sad!

[Stormtroopooper]

I'll also suggest Emilia and Emmeline.

[dreadpiratebuttercup]

Since you like the Em- beginning, I'll suggest Emmanuelle.

[claud]

Have you considered Elsa?

[SweetDee]

I love Victoria with Anna.

[bluedot]

I like the names on your list. Emma might be a bit matchy with DD1 though.

Other suggestions:
Emily
Claire
Clara
Lillian
Caroline
Elise
Elizabeth
Amelia
Margaret