top 2 boy names

[carli]

Samuel Robert or Joshua Robert

Thoughts?  (Robert is my husband's and FIL's name.  He wants to name him Robert Allen III and I'm trying to compromise.)

[dreadpiratebuttercup]

Samuel Robert

[chibiyui]

I prefer Samuel over Joshua.

[Idani]

I like them both and voted Samuel Robert.

[MauiBliss]

Samuel!

[bromios]

Joshua. Samuel has always left me a bit cold and I actively dislike the nn Sam.

[ashiscute]

I prefer Samuel but I like Joshua too.

[leahb12]

I prefer Samuel. Great name.

[kellybenelly83]

I am not the biggest fan of Samuel, though I love Sam. (ok so really I just have a thing for Sam and Dean Whinchester)

But I think Joshua is really nice.

[carli]

ok, so I'm taking away that there's really nothing wrong with either name. Thanks everyone!

[mags]

Samuel

[helenahhandbasket]

Samuel Robert! Both of these names are on my phantom boy name list.

[lexisophie55]

Samuel

[MissMarch]

Both are nice but I vote Samuel.

[puppygurl21]

I like Samuel best

[EvaAzalea]

Definitely nothing wrong with either but I prefer Joshua.

[chapter79]

Prefer Samuel

[teareading]

Another vote for Samuel!

[normadix]

Samuel Robert by a mile

[brittneysandra]

Samuel Robert!

[lulu783]

Another vote for Samuel Robert

[AleWife]

I love Samuel! It was a contender for our son.

[pbandj714]

Samuel Robert.

[washingtonqueen]

Samuel

[Widget123]

Samuel. Joshua seems a little dated to me

[amylee545]

Another for Samuel Robert!

[fisherlake]

Samuel!

[lalamomma]

I like Samuel better but I don't love Sam as a NN. I prefer Josh if your going to go by the shorter NN for either.

[Stormtroopooper]

Definitely Samuel.