Stitch fix

[cupcakesandpi]

It is slow around here so I was hoping you all would indulge me & give me some fashion advice. I signed up for stitch fix back in August & just got my 4th fix. I'm not sure what to keep. Help please because I have to return it soon. I apologize for the bad selfies.

The jeans I am wearing also came in this fix. So I got the scarf, gray & black sweater, teal shirt & cardigan.

[smalltownmoon]

Love the cardigan and grey shirt.
Meh on the scarf (I am not a scarf person though.)
Can you take a different pic of the teal shirt? I can't really tell if it works or not.

[cupcakesandpi]

Is this better?

[Deleted]

Scarf-no
Grey shirt -yes
Teal shirt- fits well and I think keep
Jeans- look like they fit well keep
Cardigan- no

[emarieme]

Agree with @jacks605, on the cardigan. It's fine, but it looks like something you can probably find cheaper than Stitch.

Teal top looks awesome on you! Very flattering.

[smalltownmoon]

cupcakesandpi LOVE THE TEAL! The jeans are good too. So basically all I don't love is the scarf.

[emmyg65]

Cardigan - no
Gray top - meh
Teal top - yes!
Jeans - yes!
Scarf - no

Like others said, the cardi is fine but I'm pretty sure you could get a similar one for $20 at Target. The gray sweater is fine but just NMS. The scarf is weird, and I say that as a scarf person and plaid obsessive.

[helenahhandbasket]

Keep the jeans, the scarf and the grey and black sweater.

Ditch the teal top (it's just a long sleeved t shirt, right?) and the cardi. They are fine, but they seem like very basic items that could be purchased anywhere.

[eyenigh]

The angles are a little weird to give a solid opinion. I really like the gray/black top but I can't really see all of it on you. Color blocking can work well in certain cases and, in others, cut you off in weird places. The cardigan looks like it's more of a cocoon style? The sleeve length looks good and I tend to like the curve on the front as it's flattering on almost all bodies. The teal top I'm not crazy about unless you were going to layer it or pair it with a much flatter front pant (maybe a legging) because the thin material of the top is showing me all the details on the pants (buttons, pocket slits, etc.). The jeans look good but the length looks jusssst right so if you ever wear a heel, I think that option would be out. Is the scarf more like a winter scarf or some other kind of blend?

[cupcakesandpi]

Thanks for all of the replies ladies! I tend to agree about the cardigan but it is cheaper for me to keep the whole box than to send it back.